Saylor's Pizza & More

4.3 ( 413 reviews )

Checking... 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM See Hours

2047 Oakland Ave, Elkhart, IN 46516, United States

+1 574-293-3683

Saylor's Pizza & More, located at 2047 Oakland Ave, Elkhart, IN, is a delightful find for pizza lovers. This no-frills eatery emphasizes quick service and affordable prices, all while delivering delicious food that has customers raving. Many patrons, like Ariana Sorensen, appreciate the walk-up style and the option for half-and-half pizzas with reasonable topping charges, making it budget-friendly and convenient. The specialty pizzas, such as the Hawaiian and Meaty options, are frequently praised for their generous toppings and perfectly baked crusts. Louis highlights the freshness and balance of ingredients, while Mini Maze enjoys the customizable slice sizes suitable for all ages. The diverse menu also features enticing sides like breadsticks, garlic bread, and mouthwatering wings, as well as hearty sandwiches, making it a complete dining experience. Beyond pizza, the menu offers standout dishes like BBQ beef tips, drawing glowing recommendations from Melanie Archer. Overall, Saylor's Pizza & More is not just a place to eat; it's a cherished local gem that leaves a lasting impression and keeps customers coming back for more. If you find yourself in Elkhart, this spot promises a warm welcome and unforgettable flavors.

Accessibility
- Has wheelchair-accessible car park
- No wheelchair-accessible seating
Service options
- Has no-contact delivery
- Offers delivery
- Offers takeaway
Popular for
- Popular for lunch
- Popular for dinner
Offerings
- Serves comfort food
- Serves late-night food
- Quick bite
Dining options
- Serves lunch
- Serves dinner
Amenities
- No toilet
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Trendy
Planning
- Doesn't accept reservations
Payments
- Accepts credit cards
- Accepts debit cards
- Accepts NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Free of charge street parking
- Free parking lot
- Plenty of parking

Ariana Sorensen

Apr 22,2025

This is one of those little gems that me and my husband love to find when we’re out of town. We actually went back for a second pizza the same day before we left! They mean it when they say “no frills.” There’s no seating or anything - just a quick walk up shop with great pizza and good prices! They also only charged us for one topping when we did a half and half pizza (pictured). A little over 10 for a large. We’ll be back if we’re ever in Elkhart!

Louis

Apr 12,2025

Omg , just got my pizza, and it's absolutely amazing,was fast, fresh, and my toppings were just the perfect amount, sauce is my favorite, and the pie was baked to perfection,budget friendly and I am definitely happy with my dinner,ty saylors team ..it was really really good..

Mini Maze

Apr 11,2025

Every time I come to this establishment, Saylor's Pizza, I am greeted with a smile. The service is super quick. Prices are reasonable for my whole family. I paid 26, for a XXL two topping pizza. My favorite I LOVE how they DO NOT AUTOMATICALLY, cut their slices into large ones it's cut perfectly for every age in our family from 2-53 years of age. The main issue that I have with this establishment is, when you walk into the doors it's a very small ordering area. Saylor's deserves more funding to get bigger.

Michael Torres

Mar 24,2025

Thus place is off the Best Pizza in town worth the drive. If you haven't tried it Your missing out! The wings are fantastic and don't forget the cake.

Melanie Archer

Mar 6,2025

Absolutely love this place. Top notch pizza and the dinners are amazing! The bbq beef tips are super tender and the portions are huge with great prices! Definitely recommend!

Crystal Coryn

Mar 3,2025

This is the 1st time we've ordered from Saylor's. We ordered 2 xl pizzas & breadsticks for the family & their pizza is amazing! My husband says its the best pizza he's had in Elkhart. The prices are very reasonable. We will definitely recommend them to everyone, & we will definitely go back.

Jovan Howard

Feb 25,2025

In my area this is a pretty good selection of food and the service was very good. The food was hot and fresh and definitely had nice sized portions. I tried it a few times before I left a review and out of the three times I went there were no issues.

Darnell Louis

Feb 12,2025

Hands-down the best pizza I’ve had in Elkhart. It has its own unique flavor with a delicious chewiness, slight char flavor and excellent thin crunchy outside. I can’t recommend this pizza enough. Bruno’s, Vesuvios, and Marcos are all good but this is BEST baby.

Saylor's Pizza & More

Amenities and More

Photos

Reviews For Saylor's Pizza & More

Add a Review

Location

Appreciated by Others